The 40 Questions Most Frequently Asked
About The Catholic Church
By Non-Catholics
33. Why Purgatory?
Where do you find purgatory and praying for the dead in the Bible?
Purgatory is a place and state where those go for a time, who die with no unrepented mortal sins on
their souls, but who still have either venial sins, or who still have temporal punishment due either for
venial sins or repented mortal sins.
We can prove the existence of purgatory from Holy Scripture and from reason.
1. OLD TESTAMENT ... in II Macabees we read:
- "And making a gathering, he sent twelve thousand drachms of silver to Jerusalem for sacrifice to be offered for the sins of the dead. ... It is therefore a holy and wholesome thought to pray for the dead that they may be loosed from sin.''
Among non-Catholics this book is generally not accepted as the word of God. However, no one
denies that it IS a reliable book of history. As such, it proves that the Jews believed in the existence
of a place in the next world where sins COULD be forgiven. We know this cannot be hell from
which there is no escape; nor can it be heaven, for nothing unclean can enter there. We know also
that Christ did not correct this belief as He would have done if it were not true.
2. NEW TESTAMENT ...
-
(a) In the Apocalypse (XXI, 27, we are told: "And there shall not enter into it anything defiled. ..."
If there were no purgatory, this would mean that God would have to send a person who died with
only the slightest venial sin on his soul to hell with all those who have committed horrible crimes.
(b) In St. Matthew's Gospel (V, 26) St. Matthew is here speaking of hell. But by inference we are
told that there IS a place we can LEAVE in the next world:
- "Amen, I say to thee, thou wilt not come out from it til thou has paid the last farthing."
From this text we conclude that there must be a purgatory, or third place, where some atonement
CAN be made after death. This cannot be hell, for we know there is no escape from hell. Nor can it
be heaven, for nothing unclean can enter heaven. There must, then, he a third place. And this place
we call "purgatory."
(c) Again we read in St. Matthew (XII, 32) that the sin against the Holy Ghost cannot be forgiven
EITHER in this world OR in the world to come. We conclude from this that there ARE sins which
can be forgiven in the next world. But they cannot be forgiven in hell, and could not exist in heaven.
Therefore, there must be a third place where they CAN be forgiven. This place we call "purgatory."
3. REASON ALSO PROVES the existence of purgatory. Most people are not such great sinners
when they die as to deserve hell; nor are most people prepared to go immediately to heaven. God's
goodness and mercy demands a place of purifying for the slight sins of those who have tried to live
according to His law.
|